Top Of The Pops - The Story - Part 2 -through to the end and oversees
Of course it was a copy
of TOTP, but how could it be anything but? Tyne Tees,
ITV's pop specialists, were entrusted with the production
of the series, and an impressive production team were
assembled. The Roxy launched in June, and one could imagine
TOTP looking at the new show and wondering if they had
anything to fear. As it turns out, they didn't - although
reasons for its failure are hard to come by. It was well-produced,
and being transmitted on a Tuesday it could claim to
be more topical than TOTP.
Yet within 10 months the series
had ended - although Tyne Tees had a run of bad luck, not
helped by ITVs lack of support for the series. It never
had a regular networked slot, and while many regions scheduled
it at 7pm (19.00hrs) other scheduled it at 6.30pm (18.30hrs)
and others, fatally at 7.30 (19.30hrs) opposite Eastenders.
An industrial dispute at the end of 1987 meant that for
a few weeks, no acts could come into the studio, meaning
the programme had to be made up of performances held over
from previous episodes and videos. Also, producing the
programme from Newcastle-upon-Tyne inevitable led to problems
enticing acts up there (a lesson TOTP learned in the 60s
with Manchester which was only half the distance from London)
- whilst they were no doubt happy to come up for The Tube, that had a loyal audience of record buyers and there was
the opportunity to perform for longer periods of time.
The Roxy only offered 3 minutes of miming in front of an
audience who hadn't turned off after Crossroads.
Eventually Thames & TVS began scheduling
the series at 12.30am (00.30hrs), and very soon TOTP
was a monopoly again. They were very fortunate as the
series was very weak at the time - Peel had left and
their only idea to counteract The Roxy (who used regular
presenters) was getting Mike Smith & Gary Davies
to do almost every show. The end of the year saw the
BBC team up with ABC to launch an (thankfully short-lived)
American version of the series, which led to a few programmes
full of boring, mushe US-derived material.
On its 25th anniversary, it was
time for another revamp, but the new set looked horrible
and the old theme tune by Paul Hardcastle (The Wizard)
remained, despite it already sounding old fashioned.
New producer Paul Ciani decided to hire new presenters,
so people like Andy Crane, Simon Parkin, Jenny Powell & Anthea
Turner started turning up, much to everyone's bemusement.
The design had started to look very tacky, and again
the programme was becoming something of an embarrassment.
By 1992, a current episode looked not dissimilar to
a 1984 episode, which wasn't a good thing. Ciani abstained
from the producer's chair due to illness and Stan Appel
returned as a temporary replacement.
Later he began to run the
entire Top 40 along the bottom of the screen under a
video midway through the programme, but this led to a
lack of structure to each show. Ciani never came back
and Appel then took charge permanently - even though
he was clearly too old to be doing so. It was decided
to completely revamp the series, in an attempt to make
it essential viewing, but what a way to do it...
With all this, TOTP ceased to become the place to find
out what was popular.
Appel's second mistake was the creation of another rule
- acts had to sing live on the programme . This was idiotic,
and pandered to the "You can't hear the words" mentality
that TOTP should not have been encouraging. Instead of
celebrating pop music for what it was, it began to penalise
it. Acts like Cathy Dennis & Dannii Minogue suffered
under the new regime, being unable to perform to their
full potential, and it wasn't as if people were buying
their records because of their fantastic singing voices.
Even more fatally this discriminated against dance acts
that within a few months had become the major force in
pop music. Acts like 2 Unlimited, Prodigy & Utah Saints
had to sing live, which they clearly weren't supposed
to do - therefore their performances on the programme
sounded nothing like their records. It's instructive
that the only praise for the new format in the Radio
Times came from a 40-year old, exactly the wrong sort
of audience that had a loyal audience of record buyers and there was
the opportunity to perform for longer periods of time.
The Roxy only offered 3 minutes of miming in front of an
audience who hadn't turned off after Crossroads.
Eventually Thames & TVS began scheduling
the series at 12.30am (00.30hrs), and very soon TOTP
was a monopoly again. They were very fortunate as the
series was very weak at the time - Peel had left and
their only idea to counteract The Roxy (who used regular
presenters) was getting Mike Smith & Gary Davies
to do almost every show. The end of the year saw the
BBC team up with ABC to launch an (thankfully short-lived)
American version of the series, which led to a few programmes
full of boring, mushe US-derived material.
This continued
for a while, and even the return of Michael Hurll as
a holiday relief in 1992 did little to brighten things
up - in fact things got even worse, as Hurll selected
a range of acts that could have meant little to the average
teenager.
A letter to the Radio Times in 1993 commiserated
the production team on the axing of the series - it hadn't
been, but the papers began suggesting that the series
was under threat. By the time it reached its 30th anniversary,
despite getting anniversary programming on BBC1 the series
was in serious doubt.
Ridiculously Stan Appel retired from the programme in
January 1994 - it still seems incredible that the programme
was produced by a man at the end of his BBC career, and
even more so when you consider he was producing Every
Second Counts at the same time. Possible his olny triumph
in his second stint was the resurrection of Meat Loaf's
career, but again, this is hardly what TOTP should be.
Appel's replacement this time didn't come from the light
entertainment department, thus breaking a tradition -
instead it was former Radio 1 producer Ric Blaxill. Blaxhill's
first changes on taking over were eminently sensible
- he allowed bands to mime, and also started using Radio
1 DJs again.
Appel had dropped these in
the re-launch. , instead using his own choice of unknown
presenters, such as Mark Franklin & Tony Dortie - However
they were all rubbish.
Blaxill soon started making further changes. He invited
celebrities to introduce the programme in rotation to
the DJs, and Angus Deayton & Andi Peters therefore made
appearances in his first few months. The number on non-chart
tracks remained , but at least they were now from acts
who had appeal to a much younger audience. It was fortunate
that Blaxill's tenure coincided with the rise in Britpop,
and the gradual resurrection of the singles chart, after
a few terrible years in the early 90s. Viewing figures
began to rise again, and there was even a live edition
in August, something they hadn't done for several years.
In September TOTP2 was launched , though in a different
format than it takes now. (The original format was better
as it catered for a wider audience).
It compiled
highlights of the previous weeks programme with some
brief archive footage and new releases - attempting to
create "a music magazine for the older record buyer".
In fact, so successful was Blaxhill's first year that
in February 1995 the Radio Times devoted 2 pages to him
and how he made TOTP great again. This coincided with
the spinoff magazine from the programme, which at the
start attempted to appeal "not to the teenybopper market"
but to music fans. For The BBC this was a treat, it coincided
with the Chris Evans inspired revival of Radio 1s fortunes,
and so the corporation was able to court a much more
attractive audience. However, it seems that Blaxill began
to believe his own publicity somewhat - he began selecting
bands for exclusives that the general public seemed to
have little interest in such as Elastica, Menswear (for
their first, limited release single) and most notoriously
Bis. Records going down the charts started to be played
for the first time.
Later William Phillips, writing in
Broadcast Magazine, was deriding him for "marginalising
the wrong kind of viewer", as viewing figures dipped
again.
Thursday 6 Jun 1997 saw Nicky
Campbell announce that we were watching "the last Thursday
TOTP for a while" - the series was moved to Friday, ostensibly
to avoid a clash with sporting events over the summer,
and the BBC told us it would return to Thursdays in the
autumn. However, other factors seemed to be at work - over
the summer the only sporting events on a Thursday were
one football match and 2 weeks of the Olympics. The Olympics
however, were also on a Friday, and the show was moved
over to BBC2 for those 2 weeks. It became obvious that
this schedule change was to test the water for a permanent
move.
The programme moved to 7pm (19.00hrs) on Fridays which
could have been a better slot - Emmerdale was now getting
a large audience opposite TOTP on Thursdays, and in its
new slot the opposition was Shane Richie's terrible Lucky
Numbers quiz show. However, Friday night has traditionally
very weak for the corporation, and ITVs double-bill of
Coronation Street and The Bill could always be guaranteed
to get a large audience.
TOTP suffered by losing parts
of the young audience (who would be going out on Fridays)
and the family audience who would normally stick with ITV.
Also, the programme moved further away from the charts
which were now published on Sundays instead of Tuesdays
as it once was. We'd already heard the new chart 5 days
ago, and given the concentration on new releases, we'd
already heard the records that were expected to chart the
following week.
Given that the series was "on probation" then, it seemed
sensibly for Blaxill to stick to a family friendly format.
But not a bit of it. The first Friday edition featured
just 20 minutes of records in the chart, the final third
being devoted to Paul Weller who performed extended
The the Germans got in on the act in 1998.
Here's Tokio Hotel from early 2007
...followed by Holland - Here's one of their
top female stars - ILSE DELANGE
versions of The Changing Man, which was over a year old
and Peacock Suit, which wasn't going to be released for
ages. Two weeks later the reformed Sex Pistols played
2 live tracks.
What seemed to be happening was that Blaxill was feeling
TOTP lacked credibility, which may have been the case,
but it was equally uncool in the Hurll years.
Crucially
TOTP was still a prime-time entertainment programme,
and as someone once said of Radio 1 at the same time
"people tend not to want to listen to the same thing
all day everyday". In August, The Sun printed an article
headlined "Top Of The Pops gets smallest ever audience".
The previous week's edition get just 2.8 million viewers
- admittedly it had been broadcast on BBC2, but the Friday
figures on the whole were disappointing.
Nevertherless, it was expected that, as promised, the
programme would return to its familiar slot on Thursdays
in September. The BBC began to trail its new series of
The Muppets, which was going to go out at 7pm (19.00hrs)
on Fridays, so it looked hopeful. Opening up The Radio
Times, then, that week, we flipped straight to 7pm (19.00hrs)
Thursdays to find...Watchdog. The new schedules found
TOTP stuck on a Friday - and at 7.25pm (19.25hrs). This
meant the programme was up against Coronation Street
on ITV, and it was obvious which would lose out. Despite
the extra 5 minutes (due to The Muppets being a US export
thus only 25 minutes duration), this was a massive demotion.
Some artists
became reluctant to appear, and viewing figures sunk
further. After The Muppets finished, TOTP then moved
to a more consistant start time of 7.30pm (19.30hrs),
which meant that the casual viewer have already switched
over to ITV before it started. There were also many more
interuptions to the slot - Children In Need & Comic Relief
would mean it moving at least every 6 months, and it
now always moved to BBC2, rather than a different night
on BBC1.
Italian show presenters
Zartl & Tillmann
Holland rockers - BEEF
7.30pm (19.30hrs),
which meant that the casual viewer have already switched
over to ITV before it started. There were also many more
interuptions to the slot - Children In Need & Comic Relief
would mean it moving at least every 6 months, and it
now always moved to BBC2, rather than a different night
on BBC1.
Blaxill remained producer for a bit longer, introtucing
a "flashback" feature , and the BBC gace the series a
Saturday repeat to make up for it. However after a few
weeks scheduling around midnight, the repeat started
going out about 1.00am (01.00hrs), which was far too
late. Finally in January 1997, Blaxill announced his
departure, leaving to join a new record label (he would
retern to TV a few months later with LWT., and produced
the early editions of SM:TV Live - programmes that Ant
& Dec now refer to as "embarrassing".
His last
month on the programme saw a mix of guest presenter who
had little to do with current pop at all - Noddy Holder,
Ardal O'Hanlon & Phil Daniels amongst others.
His replacement from March was Mark Wells, an established
light entertainment producer - this was a bit of a throwback
to the early days. Despite only being in charge for 3
months, changes were made - exclusives became less frequent,
the programme concentrating on the chart more and the
personality presenter took a back seat. More presenters
came from Radio 1 (including on 2 occasions Mark & Lard)
and others were your basic telegenic babe, a la Dannii
Minogue, Jayne Middlemiss & Sarah Cawood who did several
shows in this period. Of most interest is a edition in
May when for the first time ever, every act performed
in the studio - the first for many, many years without
a video. Even during the Blaxill era there was at least
one video, normally for technical reasons - the show
was recorded in one go, so a video allowed for a break,
as the chart could be run over it.
However,
this era began to utilise recording in batches more -
acts would perform in the studio whenever they were available,
and the performance wouild be recorded and slotted in
if & when the single made the charts.
A permanent new producer arrived in 1997 - Chris Cowey
was a former producer of Channel 4's "White Room" and
had many years experience as a music producer at Tyne
Tees (he'd worked on The Tube). This seemed high-faluting for
TOTP, coming from "serious" music programmes rather than
light entertainment. However, Cowey had a successful
first period in charge. He seemed to learn from Hurll's
model, so acts performed on large stages, with the audience
in vision, and the programme looked visually more exciting.
More creativity was apparent in set design and in the
presentation of the acts - often short inserts were filmed
earlier and incorporated into the performance. After
experimenting with presenters (people such as Sarah Cawood
and Denise Van Outen turning up for one-off shows), he
began to settle on a regular team, which became Jo Whiley,
Jayne Middlemiss and Zoe Ball. The programme became more
stable, and viewing figures increased.
And this
is almost where we leave it - unfortunately the series
couldn't improve on these developments, and there's
an air of tiredness about the programme again. The set
hasn't changed for nearly three years, and so many performance
are now recorded in advance that the programme often
resembles a clip show. Some tracks are now flogged
to death, while others are totally ignored - Cowey "banned" videos,
insisting that bands turned up, but this has lead to
some ridiculous situations, with Funkstar Deluxe not
appearing on the programme last year despite being
at number three.
Worse still, a scheduling change to Top Of The Pops
2 brought it into a much more user-friendly Wednesday
evening slot (from Saturdays) and a massively increased
audience. The new format utilises archive material and
selected performances from Top Of The Pops to appeal
to a much wider age range. Recently, an edition of Top
Of The Pops 2 got more viewers than that week's Top Of
The Pops. With Pops now moving to BBC2 on numerous occasions,
will we see the loss of a regular prime-time pop show?
The format has just been sold to America again, which
was a mistake last time - will it happen again?
A new-look
- including a fresh logo, title sequence and signature
music - was launched on Friday 1 May 1998. The changes
include a brand-new version of 'Whole Lotta Love'. The
famous theme tune has been completely re-worked by Bad
Man Bad. The show, now broadcast on BBC-1 at 7.30 pm
each Friday night, is hosted by a regular team of presenters,
including Jamie Theakston, Jayne Middlemiss and Gail
Porter.
Whatever the changes, however, the essence of the
show - that precious format - remains untouched.
The show has become so popular that it is now shown
in over 80 countries worldwide, most with their own
shows and artists. Some such as Germany have slightly
different shows with added content such as Top News
all about what the top artists of the day are doing
and also a competition. Most again such as the shows
in Germany and Holland they are longer than in the
UK, their shows are 1 hour long , whereas in the UK
they are only 30 minutes.
In 2003 a new producer came in after Chris Cowey
left. The new producer Andi Peters. He came from children's
television and turned out to be the show's worst ever
producer. The acts and music genre on the show became
more & more to his own personal taste. In part, due to this fact the ratings
sunk lower & lower and with a new presenter Tim Kash
who also turned out to be the worst presenter in the the show's history, rating fell to
rock bottom. The BBC tried to revive it somewhat by switching
it to BBC on Sundays and linking with TOTP2. From here
on the show was dead in the UK.
R.I.P.
- TOP OF THE POPS
click HERE for all the logos and listen to all the theme tunes